The cases / Consulting / government / healthcare
Deloitte's C$1.6M Newfoundland health staffing plan cited papers that don't exist
Plan released May 2025; errors reported Nov 22, 2025.
What the AI said
At least four citations, including 'The cost-effectiveness of a rural retention program for registered nurses in Canada' and 'The cost-effectiveness of local recruitment and retention strategies for health workers in Canada'.
What was actually true
Named co-authors said the first citation is 'false' and the second paper 'does not exist'. Deloitte acknowledged four citations were incorrect.
Cost or impact
The province paid Deloitte C$1,598,485 for the 526-page plan. By March 2026 the government was 'reviewing options related to compensation', and vendors must now disclose AI use; the province can audit it. Deloitte stands by the findings.
Who caught it
The Independent (theindependent.ca), Justin Brake.
Check that would have caught it Our analysis
source citation. Resolve every reference to a real record (DOI, journal page) before sign-off.
This is our judgment, not something the sources say. How we assign it.
Sources
- theindependent.cahttps://theindependent.ca/news/lji/major-n-l-healthcare-report-contains-errors-likely-generated-by-a-i/
- cbc.cahttps://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/nl-deloitte-citations-9.6990216
- cbc.cahttps://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/nl-procurement-ai-9.7123532
Links last checked Oct 24, 2026. If something here is wrong, send a correction.